Hand dryers vs paper towels: which method is cleaner?
A new study finds that a typical air-based hand dryer leaves more contamination on poorly washed hands than paper towels.
A hand dryer can also spread germs and bacteria onto clothing and other surfaces.
“On average, the levels of contamination were 10-fold higher following jet air dryer use than after paper towel use,” the authors conclude.
The study was published today (March 17) in the journal Infection Control & Hospital Epidemiology.
Hand dryers vs paper towels: past research
Prior research has shown that healthcare workers often ignore the recommended handwashing practices.
In fact, average adherence is only 40%.
So to better understand hand drying’s impact on hygiene, the researchers, based at the University of Leeds in the UK, conducted an experiment to learn the role of different hand drying methods.
They wanted to see which methods were most likely to spread germs from poorly washed hands beyond the restroom.
For the study, volunteers sanitized their hands with 70% alcohol disinfectant, and then dipped them in a nonharmful viral solution.
Next, they dried their hands using either using an air-based hand dryer or paper towels.
Paper towel drying took an average of 12 seconds, using 3–5 towels.
Jet air drying lasted 10 seconds, on average.
During the experiment, volunteers wore an apron to test the contamination of clothing.
The subjects then walked along a predetermined path through the hospital.
On the way, they touched commonly used surfaces, such as elevator buttons.
The researchers then collected samples from the surfaces that volunteers touched, and also from the aprons.
For example, they placed a stethoscope around their neck, leaving it in contact with the apron for seven minutes.
They also crossed their arms across their chest for two minutes, and placed them on the arms of a chair for three minutes.
Results: jet air dryers lead to more contamination
On average, the levels of contamination to surfaces volunteers touched with their hands were ten times higher after their hands were dried with an air dryer than with paper towels, the study found.
“Bacteriophage dispersal across hospital surfaces was more frequently detected after hands were dried using a jet air dryer than using paper towels,” the authors write.
“On average, the levels of contamination were 10-fold higher following jet air dryer use than after paper towel use.”
And contamination from transferred onto surfaces only following jet air dryer use, not paper towel use.
The authors suggest this is due to “splattering” when using a jet hand dryer.
Researchers also saw more microbial transfer to the apron when volunteers used the air dryer.
Furthermore, the transfer of microbes to the study participants’ clothing after using the air dryer also contributed to the spread of germs.
Hand dryers vs paper towels: which kills more germs?
Based on the contamination levels following hand drying using a high-speed air dryer, said co-author Ines Moura, “we question the choice of air dryers in healthcare settings.”
“Microbes remaining after hand drying can transfer to surfaces via contaminated hands and clothing,” Moura said.
“The study was performed in a healthcare setting,” Moura said, “and has important lessons for health institutions that still have high-speed air dryers in restrooms.”
But, she added, “the results are also relevant for public restrooms with high foot traffic.”
How Reliable Are the Findings of Studies Comparing Hand Dryers and Paper Towels?
Some studies point to hand dryers being more hygienic, while others favor paper towels.
It’s important to critically assess the methodology before drawing conclusions.
Future research on the paper towels vs. hand dryers question
Future studies on hand dryer germs should look at how the method and length of handwashing affect the degree of bacteria transfer and surface contamination.
Contamination of hands during hand drying in a restroom, the authors summarize, can result in microbe dissemination to multiple surfaces in the hospital environment.
“This phenomenon,” they write, “is significantly more likely to occur after hand drying with a jet air dryer as opposed to a paper towel.”
Study: “From the hospital toilet to the ward: a pilot study on microbe dispersal to multiple hospital surfaces following hand drying using a jet air dryer versus paper towels.”
Authors: Ines Moura, Duncan Ewin, Mark Wilcox
Published in: Infection Control & Hospital Epidemiology
Publication date: March 17, 2021
Picture: by Martin Slavoljubovski from Pixabay
The latest in psychology news:
- Cautiously optimistic: new study finds that unrealistic optimism actually decreases happiness.
- This new study finds not knowing how to flirt is the main reason behind “involuntary singlehood.”
- Recent research has found that calling versus texting (or e-mailing) isn’t nearly as awkward as people expect.
- Why do couples look alike more and more as time passes? A new study finds that in fact there’s no evidence for this popular notion.
- New research on “indirect aggression” — also known as meanness – finds that mean children often grow into mean adults.